The increased migration of skilled workers globally has led to a focus in the immigration literature on the economic costs of unsuccessful labour market integration. Less attention has been given to the consequences of employment difficulties, such as those related to over-education, on aspects of immigrants’ subjective well-being. Although a large proportion of immigrants experience over-education, studies examining the relationship between over-education and life satisfaction tend to concentrate on the general population.
These studies find a negative relationship between over-education and life satisfaction. Since immigrant and Canadian-born (non-immigrant) workers may experience over-education differently, it is important to examine this relationship in both groups. This study examines how over-education is associated with life satisfaction among university-educated immigrant and non-immigrant workers in Canada, and accounts for differences in the degree of over-education in each group.
Results indicate that over-education was negatively associated with life satisfaction among immigrants and non-immigrants, although the effect was weaker in the immigrant population. Income was the main factor mediating the negative relationship between over-education and life satisfaction among immigrants. Furthermore, this relationship weakened with immigrants’ increased residence in Canada. This may suggest that over-education is less influential in immigrants’ assessment of life satisfaction over time, or the effect of over-education is weaker among earlier arrival cohorts. Results also indicated that the negative relationship between over-education and life satisfaction was weaker for immigrants from developing countries compared with those from developed countries.
Chosen excerpts by Job Market Monitor. Read the whole story at Over-education and Life Satisfaction among Immigrant and Non-immigrant Workers in Canada
Related Posts
Immigration in Canada – Prior host-country work experience as a criteria would improve integration
Recent changes to immigration selection policies favor skilled workers with prior work experience in the immigrant host country. Using unique administrative tax data for Canada, we estimate earnings equations to quantify the difference in earnings of immigrants with prior Canadian experience (prefilers) and those without prior experience (non-prefilers). We find that, relative to non-prefilers, entry … Continue reading
Economic Immigration in Canada – The processing time is 67 months
In the economic class, if an application was filed between 2008 and 2010, the processing time is 67 months while for the ones filed between 2010 and 2014, is 13 months. Canada takes in about 260,000 immigrants each year in all categories, combined. The statistics were not available for last year, but in 2014, 66,661 … Continue reading
L’Immigration au Canada – Une dévaluation persistante des titres de compétences non canadiens
Même si la plupart des études récentes ne vont pas au-delà des données du recensement de 2006, les nouvelles analyses révèlent clairement que le problème de l’inadéquation entre l’emploi et la scolarité ainsi que les compétences persiste et même s’aggrave. Alors que l’analyse de l’Enquête sur la population active de 2005-2008 montre une certaine amélioration des … Continue reading
L’immigration au Canada – Les obstacles à la reconnaissance des qualifications
Un grand nombre d’immigrants éprouvent des difficultés à faire reconnaître leurs compétences, leur formation et leur expérience, malgré les nombreux efforts déployés dans les provinces et territoires. Pour beaucoup de ces immigrants, le système est complexe et souvent frustrant. Les systèmes de réglementation professionnelle au Canada ont été essentiellement conçus à l’intention des personnes qui … Continue reading
Immigration in Canada in 2016 – The most immigrants it has since the 1910s
Following Immigration Minister John McCallum’s speech on March 8, 2016 at the Brampton Multicultural Community Centre, many were left wondering about the direction presented for this year. While Minister McCallum was quoted saying that this is a “significant shift” in policy, it remains to be seen when these changes will be implemented, and of the … Continue reading
Canada / Increases in immigration level bring immigrants real wages down
The annual level of immigration is one of the most critical components of a country’s immigration policy. It is difficult to directly compare the costs and benefits of changing immigration levels because immigration can serve multiple goals. However, some narrowly-defined effects can be empirically assessed. This study considers solely the potential influence of immigration levels … Continue reading
Job Market Monitor 
Discussion
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
Pingback: Basic Skills of Immigrants in Canada in PIAAC – Lower proficiency scores than the Canadian-born in all three skills | Job Market Monitor - April 4, 2018