This article reviews practices in the United States (US) federal‐state unemployment insurance (UI) system regarding applicant eligibility, benefit generosity, benefit financing and emergency measures with the aim of revealing lessons for a possible European unemployment benefit system (EUBS) for European Union (EU) Member States.
We overview the US system for UI and examine important areas of federal leadership. While the US system offers some good ideas for setting up an EUBS, there are also lessons in some shortcomings of the US experience. We overview existing national UI systems in the EU and review the debate on an EUBS in the EU. We identify areas of risk for individual and institutional moral hazard in a multi‐tiered UI system and give examples of monitoring methods and incentives to ameliorate such risks. We suggest approaches for gradual system development, encouraging lower‐tier behaviour, benefit financing, and responses to regional and system‐wide labour market crises.
Chosen excerpts by Job Market Monitor. Read the whole story @ Lessons from the American federal‐state unemployment insurance system for a European unemployment benefits system
Related posts
Unemployment Insurance In US – Extending benefits to workers in precarious and and nonstandard jobs
Many fear that rapid technical change is raising the rate at which workers are displaced from their jobs, as machines take over many tasks once performed by humans (Brynjolfsson and McAfee, 2014). By shifting the locus of production of many goods from advanced economies to emerging and developing ones, globalization also has contributed to worker … Continue reading
Global Economic Crisis / More than 70 per cent of workers lack unemployment insurance
The recent global economic crisis has served as a stark reminder of why unemployment insurance matters. But the reality is that fewer than half of almost 200 countries monitored by the ILO offer such protection. More than 70 per cent of workers worldwide have no statutory access to unemployment insurance or any type of unemployment … Continue reading
Public Employment Service in US – USDOL has neglected strengthening the partnership with Unemployment Insurance research finds
The Employment Service-Unemployment Insurance (ES-UI) partnership is rooted in permanent authorizing statutes, an identical fund source, common rules for state administration, and interdependent practices to guard against improper payments and expose claimants to suitable job openings. This partnership is central to the success of the public workforce system. Over the past several decades, USDOL has … Continue reading
COVID and UI in US – Changes in state Unemployment Insurance rules
The COVID-19 pandemic led to an unprecedented expansion in unemployment insurance (UI) eligibility across states. While more than forty states had modified UI rules by the end of March, not all states responded in the same way. In this article, I summarize the changes to state UI rules in response to the crisis and explore … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US – State reserves are not adequate before COVID-19
The federal-state unemployment insurance (UI) system pays temporary partial earnings replacement to involuntarily unemployed applicants while they are actively seeking reemployment. The UI system is an automatic stabilizer for state economies, injecting spending from benefit payments quickly in economic downturns, and withdrawing spending during business recoveries because of fewer beneficiaries and higher tax contributions. There … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in Germany – The impact of the Hartz reforms
A key question in labor market research is how the unemployment insurance system affects unemployment rates and labor market dynamics. A new IZA Discussion Paper by Benjamin Hartung, Philip Jung and Moritz Kuhn revisits this old question studying the German Hartz reforms. The study traces the German labor market miracle back to the reform of … Continue reading
Employment Insurance Coverage in Canada, 2017 – Eligibility rate down for youth and for people aged 45 and over
The eligibility rate for receiving regular Employment Insurance (EI) benefits was 84.3% in 2017, little changed from the previous year. The eligibility rate was also little changed for men and women, but was down for youth and those aged 45 and over. Infographic Employment Insurance coverage and eligibility Eligibility rate down for youth and for people aged 45 and … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US – How to improve it
Some researchers and policymakers have reasonably worried that generous UI could discourage serious job search and raise workers’ wage demands unrealistically (an instance of what economists call “moral hazard”), thereby slowing the overall labor market recovery. To be clear, most labor economists do not share the worry that unemployment is increased much by UI. But … Continue reading
The work test for unemployment insurance (UI) recipients – Reduced time to reemployment by 1–2 quarters for permanent job losers
The work test for unemployment insurance (UI) recipients has been a central part of UI in the United States since the system began in the 1930s. In general, to be eligible for UI benefits, a claimant initially needs an adequate work history and must have lost her job through lack of work and no fault … Continue reading
Employment Insurance in Canada – Five key changes
Last federal budget outlined multiple changes coming to the employment insurance program that combined will have a total cost this year of $1.02 billion and almost $1.45 billion next year. Here are five key changes: 1) The Liberals are promising to add five weeks of eligibility up to a maximum of 50 weeks of regular … Continue reading
The implementation of a European unemployment insurance – A report
The implementation of a European unemployment insurance system could begin with the creation of a eurozone budget; a time-consuming but popular idea, according to the French Council of Economic Analysis. The idea of a common system of unemployment insurance within the eurozone is taking off. The need to strengthen the budgetary policy of the single … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US – The President’s proposal
The President’s proposal contains three core elements: Protecting Workers with Wage Insurance: The President’s plan would ensure workers have access to wage insurance that would replace half of lost wages, up to $10,000 over two years. Displaced workers making less than $50,000 who were with their prior employer for at least three years would be … Continue reading
Employment Insurance (EI) in Canada – The current system is broken former chief actuary says
Only about 40 per cent of Canada’s 1.3 million unemployed people now receive benefits. And among those who do, the range of benefits given in the largest labour-market program in the country varies widely among regions. The current system is broken, said Michel Bédard, who co-wrote a paper to be released Thursday with economics professor … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US – The proportion of jobless workers receiving benefits fell to a record low of 23.1 percent in December 2014
The Great Recession and its aftermath created severe challenges for unemployment insurance (UI) programs in the United States and for jobless workers relying upon them. In this briefing paper, we show that state UI programs are failing their critical goals of income replacement and supporting economic growth. The proportion of jobless workers receiving benefits from … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US – Cut in benefit duration accounted for about 61 percent of the aggregate employment growth in 2014 NBER’s study finds
Our objective in this paper is to assess the effect of unemployment benefit extensions on employment. Measuring the magnitude of this effect is manifestly important for understanding the economic consequences of this widely used policy instrument. Yet, the existing literature provides little information on the size, let alone the sign of this effect. In the … Continue reading
For an European unemployment insurance – A Commission Report
The best idea for an EMU-level automatic fiscal stabiliser is in my view a scheme where fiscal stimulus is provided to countries of the monetary union based on developments in their short-term unemployment. Unemployment is an indicator whose big advantages are that it very closely follows developments in the economic cycle, it is easily understandable, … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in Germany
Until 2005, Germans who were out of work and in need would receive 60% of the net salary of their last job 67% if they had children, tax free, then after a year, it would go down to 53%. Former chancellor Gerhard Schröder made it his mission to change this system, a programme known as … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US / Worse than most other developed countries (video)
Long-term unemployment in the U.S. is twice as high as it was before the financial crisis. That\’s according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Yet Congress did not extend unemployment benefits in the latest budget deal. Less well known is how the U.S. has one of the least generous unemployment insurance systems in … Continue reading
Unemployment Insurance in US / Has it increased joblessness ?
House-Senate negotiators are close to a modest budget accord to avoid another government shutdown, but suddenly the White House is introducing a last-minute demand. Five years into an economic recovery that President Obama often hails as miraculous, he wants to extend unemployment benefits one more time. Maybe it’s time to consider whether the big expansion … Continue reading
Canada / Create the Employment Insurance Savings Account says the Canadian Taxpayers Federation
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation suggests that working Canadians be entitled to keep the $4,277 currently plundered from them and their employer every year in EI premiums, rather than sending the money to Ottawa, to be processed and shipped elsewhere Continue reading
The ‘Optimal’ unemployment insurance
Benefit-extension programmes reduce competition for jobs. Since the programme induces eligible job seekers to search less hard, non-eligible job seekers face lower competition and find jobs more easily Continue reading
Job Market Monitor 
Discussion
No comments yet.