When Vancouver’s Fairmont Waterfront Hotel posted an ad for unpaid interns to work busing tables in its dining room (“As a Busperson, you will take pride in the integral role you play in supporting your Food and Beverage Colleagues…”) it quickly set off a firestorm in social media — and an uneasy silence elsewhere.
Sensing a PR debacle in the making, the hotel quickly took down the ad. Unpaid internships have become a sensitive issue, the subject of lawsuits in both the U.S. and Canada from former interns demanding to be paid for the work they had done. To many of the commenters flaming the hotel online, the practice was clearly barbaric, a throwback to the days of child labour or worse. “At least the chimneysweeps got paid” seemed to be the general sentiment.
Yet walk into any media outlet, MP’s office, or NGO, the kinds of folks who usually get up in arms about this sort of thing, and chances are you will find an unpaid intern or three performing some menial task. And not only there. Hard data is scarce, but rough estimates of the number of unpaid interns run into the hundreds of thousands.
That has critics, at least the ones who aren’t hiring them themselves, cranking up the rhetoric. When a Tory senator advertised for an unpaid intern, he was accused of “slapping young Canadians in the face.” According to Andrew Langille, a Toronto labour lawyer, “the message to youth is: you’re worthless, you aren’t deserving of a wage, and I can exploit you with impunity.” A writer for iPolitics calls interns the “new Canadian underclass.”
Why employers would be so eager to make use of them is not hard to fathom. Theoretically the employer is not supposed to derive any benefit from taking them on — they’re supposed to be training, not doing work that could be done by paid employees — at least in the three provinces that regulate the practice. But who’s kidding whom?
What’s harder to explain is why the kids accept the offers. The easy answer (it’s exploitation, innit?) seems harder to apply in a case where the pay is not low, but zero. People may be hard up enough for cash to take a lousy, low-wage job — it’s better than nothing, after all — but when the pay is not, in fact, better than nothing, why not just stay home? Plainly they must feel they are getting something in return: not as much as they’d like, but enough to make it worth their time.
Chosen excerpts by Job Market Monitor. Read the whole story at
Though the laws are clear, employers in competitive, creative fields have ignored them. As the ranks of the unemployed have swelled and the surplus of jobless college students and grads has grown, increasing numbers of people young and old have been signing on for unpaid internships, wanting to make contacts and accumulate résumé lines that … Continue reading »
Serious concerns have been raised tonight about the punishing hours endured by interns at City investment banks following the death of a young Bank of America Merrill Lynch employee. At the same time, the White House under pressure to pay its interns Continue reading »
More auditors in Hong Kong can expect to be taking extra-long holidays, courtesy of the city’s sluggish IPO market. This week, accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers announced that to help avoid layoffs, employees in mainland China and Hong Kong will be offered a chance to take an additional 12 days’ holiday in the coming months, of which … Continue reading »
Every year several million students, career changers and other job seekers get internships in companies large and small. Some of those employers — small ones in particular — won’t offer internships ever again. “It’s just not worth it,” the owner of one small company in the service industry told me. “I wanted to offer people … Continue reading »
AS ANY middle-class parent knows, unpaid work experience can give youngsters a valuable introduction to a secure job. The coalition government has recognised it too, scrapping rules in 2011 that had formerly stopped 16- to 24-year-olds from doing unpaid work while claiming unemployment benefit. But moving from that to forcing them to work gratis in … Continue reading »
Boots says it is withdrawing from the government’s scheme to help the long-term unemployed find work. It comes on the same day that ministers had to drop sanctions from a separate scheme that offers work experience to younger jobseekers. Boots said that it would no longer be offering any new placements on the work programme, … Continue reading »
The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) is warning that recent headlines, which associate voluntary unpaid work experience with slave labour, are in danger of discouraging employers from offering placements and denying young people a route into permanent employment. Good quality work experience provides an invaluable way for young people to build key skills … Continue reading »
I was relatively lucky when I graduated. I only worked unpaid for around six weeks – four weeks at a think tank and two weeks here – before a newspaper started paying me to write. Lucky, because that was near enough as long as I could afford to stay in London. Had I been forced … Continue reading »